Skip to main content

Not the Point of High Speed Rail

Track Twenty-Nine draws my attention to this article about South Bend, Indiana's lobbying for a stop along a proposed high speed rail corridor. One thing concerns me, though:
If the federal government approves funding for a high-speed rail line through South Bend, passengers here could travel to Chicago's Union Station in just one hour. Such a project would have a profound effect on life in South Bend, making it easier for residents to commute to jobs in the Windy City, local officials say.
There are a lot of good reasons to invest in high speed rail infrastructure. Extreme commuting isn't one of them. Now, this article doesn't specify that people would use this for their daily commute, but there are reasons to think that's the case.

(from flickr user satosphere)

I've heard this argument applied elsewhere. While recently discussing the 3-C Corridor in Ohio, someone said, "wouldn't it be great if we had high-speed rail here?.. you could live in Cleveland and work in Columbus!" Frankly, I don't think it would be very great.

To start, there seems to be an assumption that high speed rail will be very affordable. There is really no basis for this belief. The Acela line in the Northeast (and the closest thing we have to high speed rail in this country) has very expensive fares. To travel from Philadelphia to New York City (about the same distance as South Bend to Chicago) can cost over $100 each way. Doing that twice a day for a week would run you a thousand bucks. Even if they cut you a big discount for being a frequent rider, the price tag would still be very high.

The reality is that the hour-trip promise is a station-to-station estimate, which doesn't take into account that almost nobody lives or works on top of these stations. At the end of the day, you're still looking at a round trip commute well over two hours. It's hard to see it being a realistic option for many people. It's just too far. We should really stop thinking about distance in terms of time, and start thinking about distance in terms of, well, distance.


Colby said…
I've seen somewhere else a comment about thinking in terms of distance instead of time. Can you explain the benefit or reason for such an approach? Whenever I ask 'How far?', I don't really care about the distance - and when I receive the answer 'XX miles', I do the calculation in my head to determine the time it would take to travel. Thanks.
B. P. Beckley said…
It is interesting that people think that high speed rail would be intrinsically cheaper than air travel, and there's no particular reason to assume that's true. A high speed trainset (180mph, let's say) is probably comparable in size and sophistication to an airplane of similar capacity, so why would the equipment cost be an order of magnitude lower? Yeah, trains don't have turbofans, but airplanes don't need 10000hp worth of electrical gear.

The energy use is probably lower, I guess, but that's just a function of the lower speed. A 180mph capable roadbed requires tremendous amounts of maintenance on every mile, and air travel doesn't really even have an equivalent cost.

It's an interesting mental tic. People forget how much the prices for air travel have come down. There's some nominal level in their heads for how much it should cost to get from place to place, and air travel is allowed to be much more expensive than that, but rail travel isn't.

Popular posts from this blog

In Praise of Southwest's 'C' Boarding Group

A few weeks ago I saw a tweet from someone complaining that their Southwest Airlines boarding pass had been assigned A20 (meaning they would be at least one of the first twenty passengers to board the plane). Apparently this person though they should have been assigned a higher number, less their flight experience be considerably spoiled.

Despite the complaints, Southwest has resisted demands to assign seats on its flights, a decision which I personally applaud. I'll admit that I was skeptical when they rolled out the newest boarding procedure, assigning both boarding groups and a line number; but in hindsight it seems like one of the best operational decisions they've ever made. If nothing else, it effectively eliminated the infamous "cattle call" whereby fliers were getting to airports hours in advance and sitting in line on the floor as if they were waiting for the midnight showing of the new Star Wars movie.

When I was an intern at Southwest Airlines last winter, I…

So You Want to be a Southwest Airlines Intern?

My personal website must have pretty decent SEO - because in the past year, I've received about two dozen emails from aspiring Southwest Airlines interns looking to draw on my experience in search of their own dream internship. In the past two weeks alone a few new emails have already started rolling in...

(from flickr user San Diego Shooter)

If you've found your way here, you might be hoping for the silver bullet; a secret tip that will propel you above the competition. Unfortunately, I do not know any inside secrets. I can only share my experience as an internship candidate about two years ago and, rather than responding individually to future emails I anticipate to receive, I hope that potential interns will find the information posted here valuable.

Understand: Southwest Airlines is a very unique company. The corporate culture at Southwest is truly unlike that of nearly every other company. But you probably already knew that, since it now seems mandatory for every management,…

Commuting Meets Technology

I'm finally out of the dark ages. I got an Android smartphone over the weekend and have since been in the process of exploring the Android apps market.  One thing I've immediately noticed is the really wide range of usefulness in the apps. For example, the WeatherBug app is fantastic. It automatically determines your location and gives you exact conditions for that location. On the other end of the spectrum, Google's Goggles app is supposed to be a type of 'visual search' where you snap of photo of something and Google searches for it. In each of my attempts to use it, the app hasn't returned any search results. I even took a photo of a bottle of Pepsi (figuring it as a common houseful item) and got nothing.

Somewhere in the middle is this app called Waze. Have a look at their 'guided tour':

Some people might look at it and comment on the amazing evolution of technology or on the incredible value of social networks. To me, Waze says something important ab…